For Locums
FINDING LOCUM WORK
Overview
See how we help find you your perfect locum
How Messly works
A step-by-step guide to using Messly
Browse Jobs
See what locum jobs are available
Resources for locum doctors
The Locum Hub
POPULAR
Our top resources for finding locum work
Compare Locum Agencies
See ratings and testimonials of locum agencies
Locum Salary Calculator
POPULAR
See how much you can earn as a locum
Locum Rates Breakdown
Learn how much you can earn as a locum doctor
The Locum Academy
NEW
Rapid answers to common locum questions
The Locum Toolkit
Useful resources, services and tools for locums
Need help?
Contact Us
For F3s
For f3 doctors
F3 Hub
All our best F3 resources in one place
F3 Options
Learn about your best options for F3
How To Write The Perfect F3 CV
Our top tips for CV writing for F3s
The F3 Workbook
Our workbook to help you plan your F3
Guide To Australia
Read our Down Under guide
For Trainees
For trainees
Training Navigator
Discover the best-ranked FP rotations
Foundation Training Guides
All our guides and breakdowns for FT
Blog
Hiring Doctors
HIRING DOCTORS
For Locum Agencies
Get active locum doctors on-demand
For Healthcare Organisations
Great doctors for your business
Speak to our team
Contact Us
More
MORE
Portfolio Companion
NEW
How to structure and build your portfolio
About Us
Learn about the team behind Messly
Contact Us
Get in touch with our team
Login
Register
Login
Register
December 2022
July 5, 2023

GMC Guidance on Medical References

Whether you are a locum doctor looking to collect references for your CV, a junior doctor signing off a medical student, or a senior consultant acting as a referee for your supervisees, you should know and understand the GMC guidance and expectations on medical and professional references. 

In this article we break down the GMC’s guidance on medical references so you know what you can expect from your referees, and what is expected of you should you ever be asked to provide a reference for a colleague. 

The GMC’s Good Medical Practice lists the following statements for qualities and standards that all doctors should abide by and demonstrate at their annual appraisals and ARCP’s.  

‍

✅  ‘You must be honest and objective...’

The GMC states that references must be honest and objective. That means that you must not allow your personal feelings towards the person you are providing the reference for to influence your review of their abilities. This works two ways; you can’t rate someone higher than they deserve simply because you like them, and you also can’t rate someone lower than they deserve because you dislike them. 

This applies to all situations involving any type of reference, assessment, or appraisal of a colleague or student’s competence, performance, or conduct. 

✅  ‘You must be honest and trustworthy…and make sure that any documents you write or sign are not false or misleading.’

This means that any signed documents request or provide to others must be accurate and cannot deliberately mislead or leave out information that is relevant. If you are uncertain about the accuracy of the document you are signing, you must ‘take reasonable steps to ensure that the information is correct’, but if you are still uncertain the best policy is to refuse to sign rather than risk authenticating a false document. 

✅  ‘You must keep to the principles of equality and diversity…’

This statement refers to the appraisers moral and ethical duty to remain free of judgement and prejudice when assessing their colleagues performance. Doctors should not experience career barriers on the basis of their fixed characteristics, nor should those characteristics influence in any way a doctors ability to professionally progress.  

The GMC goes on to state that ‘the safety of patients and the public could be put at risk if you make false, exaggerated or incomplete comments about another professional’s competence or experience.’ This could be interpreted as a warning against appraisers being over-generous in their assessments of doctors on the basis of equality and diversity, resulting in unsafe practitioners being allowed to work, or an appraiser being over-critical and depriving the public of a qualified healthcare professional from being allowed to provide care when they have the required skills and knowledge to practice safely and effectively. 

✅  ‘You should include all information you are aware of that is relevant…’

Referees are obliged to share all information about a candidates professional competence and overall suitability that is relevant to a potential employer. This information must be things that the referee can substantiate, and must be presented in an objective, fair, and unambiguous way. 

This is usually about information relating to ongoing, unresolved, or past complaints about the candidate but only if they relate to the suitability of the candidate to perform their professional duties. 

It does not include information about personal or health circumstances unless these ‘have a direct bearing on their suitability for the particular post in question.’ Even so, the referee should get consent from the person they are providing the reference for, before sharing this information.

In the event that the candidate refuses to disclose information which could result in patient harm, the GMC has guidance about releasing information in the public interest, under the heading of Confidentiality. 

✅  ‘You must be prepared to explain and justify your decisions and actions.’

The GMC states that your inability to justify your decision to provide a particular reference or appraisal can result in your registration being put at risk. 

As a referee, it is important to remain objective and factual in your references wherever possible so you can justify any reviews or ratings you provide. Your reference needs to be fair to both the candidate and the prospective employer, meaning that you cannot simply provide a neutral or positive reference if you do not feel that it is an accurate reflection of the skills and abilities demonstrated by the candidate while they worked with you. 

If you are someone receiving a reference, you have the right to challenge or appeal any reference that you feel is unfair or inaccurate knowing that the referee has to be able to justify their report. If you ask for a copy of a reference from your referee, they should provide it to you though they are not legally required to. 

✅  ‘You should state the basis upon which you are making your assessment of the candidate, such as how long you have known them and in what capacity.’

This is do to with full disclosure and providing context. If you are the best person to provide a reference for someone, then you should do it even if you don’t particularly want to. However, providing context for how long you’ve known the referee for and in what capacity can help establish context for your reference. 

For example, if you worked with a student for a day, your reference will carry different weight than if you worked with them for the duration of their three month placement. 

‍We hope you found this information helpful. If you want to read more about the GMC guidance, you can find it here. Or, check out our Ultimate Guide to your Medical Portfolio where we link all of our articles about medical references, portfolios and appraisals.

Tagged:
No items found.

Find locum work on your terms

The best locum agencies together in one place, competing to find you the best locum shifts. Managed for free through your Messly account.

GET STARTED
Dr Amelia White
Clinical Lead
view All Posts
SIMILAR Posts
F3
What to Expect From a Hospital Induction
F3
F3 Stories Podcast: Dr Mike
F3
Things to Do in Your First Month as an F3 Doctor
F3
GMC Guidance on Medical References
POSTS BY TaGS
AHPRA
Australia
Doctor
ED
F3
Featured
Foundation Training
ICU
Lifestyle
Locum
MCNZ
Medical Training
New Zealand
Podcast
Trainee Doctor
Year Abroad
Subscribe
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
More Posts

You Might Also Like

F3
What to Expect From a Hospital Induction
Aug 11, 2023
 by 
Dr Amelia White
F3
F3 Stories Podcast: Dr Mike
Jul 24, 2023
 by 
Dr Amelia White
F3
Things to Do in Your First Month as an F3 Doctor
Jul 18, 2023
 by 
Dr Amelia White
F3
GMC Guidance on Medical References
Jul 5, 2023
 by 
Dr Amelia White
F3
Medical References FAQs
Jul 3, 2023
 by 
Dr Amelia White
F3
Introducing OneRef
Jun 28, 2023
 by 
Dr Amelia White

126 New Kings Road
London
SW6 4LZ
‍
T: 020 4525 5373
E: 
support@messly.co.uk

For Locums
OverviewKey FeaturesThe Locum HubThe Locum AcademyLocum Salary CalculatorCompare AgenciesThe Locum ToolkitChangelog
For Trainees
Training NavigatorFoundation Guides
For F3s
The F3 HubYour F3 OptionsWrite The Perfect CVThe F3 WorkbookChangelog
Hiring Doctors
For AgenciesFor Organisations
More
LoginThe Messly BlogThe Journal ClubAbout UsContact UsTerms of UsePrivacy PolicyChangelog
Get The App:
© 2022 Berdroot Developments Limited
Made with ❤️ in London